My daughter and her mom have started beefing about the appropriateness of clothing choices.
She's thirteen. A bit of a hellion, but much less so than either her mother or I were at that age. I am kind of unable to get my head around clothing being an issue, but I always have to be mindful of how much residual "oi, oi, oi" I have left in me. And with some people that I respect a lot so adamant in defense of proper and adequate coverage, or whatever the standard is, I'm kind of shaky on where I stand.
Speaking of people I respect a lot, any opinions from the spag gallery?
***I did not mean to post this is AI. If someone wants to pop it over to Apple Talk, that's where it was meant to live.
Post-move bump
I'm like you NoLeDeMiel, so I can't help.
For me, clothing is the stuff you put on your body to prevent the screams.
It usually works.
I'm supposed to be the best man at a wedding in a suit and stuff. I'm pretty sure I can suppress the tie/choking-related panicattack long enough to get through the ceremony but the whole suit thing just baffles me. I told my friend to dress me and tell me how my hair should look and that seems to be working.
Quote from: NoLeDeMiel on August 28, 2014, 04:34:18 PM
My daughter and her mom have started beefing about the appropriateness of clothing choices.
She's thirteen. A bit of a hellion, but much less so than either her mother or I were at that age. I am kind of unable to get my head around clothing being an issue, but I always have to be mindful of how much residual "oi, oi, oi" I have left in me. And with some people that I respect a lot so adamant in defense of proper and adequate coverage, or whatever the standard is, I'm kind of shaky on where I stand.
Speaking of people I respect a lot, any opinions from the spag gallery?
***I did not mean to post this is AI. If someone wants to pop it over to Apple Talk, that's where it was meant to live.
I always allowed my kids to dress as they pleased at about age 12, so long as it wouldn't get them arrested. Same thing with hairstyles. They turned out fine.
One less thing for kids to rebel against, you see. And rebellion is NOT inevitable, and is in fact often reasonable. It's just that kids lack the communication skills to express their viewpoint, and adults never listen to kids anyway, even if they think they do.
My parents were pretty laid back and never gave me much grief. But I was always the jeans and t-shirt kind of girl, but I did have some interesting wardrobe choices when the situation called for it.
I don't have my own children, but, as a woman who was once a young woman in her teens, as long as she is comfortable and it doesn't get her in trouble in school with the stupid dress codes, go for it. I could say, "Oh, be modest, wear this, wear that..." but a woman can and SHOULD always feel confident about her body and in her clothing choices. If it is a bit too sexualized or revealing, it's not my place to judge. You guys are still her parents and will always have the final say. Let her experiment and find a style she likes, and be supportive.
In the end, it was my school that bothered me more about a tank top than my parents ever did. We lived in Florida, and they didn't allow spaghetti straps. WTF?
I never saw much point in battling with kids over their clothing. Last time I saw your kid she looked like a little girl, but if she has reached a point where she no longer looks like a little girl I definitely would suggest a talk with your daughter that goes along the lines of "Because your body looks like a woman's body, you may start getting unwanted attention from creepy older men, and I just wanted that to not take you by surprise. You don't have to be polite about it, feel free to loudly tell them to fuck off, or threaten to call the police".
Mostly, kids at that age are starting to feel like sexy beings and want to dress like sexy beings to celebrate and experiment with their newfound almost-adult bodies. It's far more important to provide parental support at that age than attempt to exert parental control; if you tell them it's her choice but that certain things make you uncomfortable because of <reasons>, and they are good reasons and not "because you look like a slut", they are likely to respect and listen to your opinions. As long as you don't revert to exerting control when they don't listen to your reasons.
In adolescence, parents do best acting as scaffolding and support systems for their budding independence. They need us to be there as advisors and support, and they need our love and approval even more than they did in middle childhood, as well as appropriate boundaries like teaching them to live respectfully in a household with other people, but they also have a drive to be independent and trying to control their expressions of independence pushes them away and damages their trust.
Gah. And then all these months later my girl makes a FB post about how girls need to show more self respect and stop "dressing like that." This possibility was very much on my mind when her mom started restricting her clothing choices. It's so tricky when we're not on the same page.
She got a lot of likes from a lot of the adults in her life. Not from me. We had a PM conversation instead about slut-shaming and agency and respect and stuff and stuff. She finally tells me that she doesn't like seeing people make decisions that are going to cause them to be viewed poorly. I told her that we care about the same things...people not being viewed poorly, but that the only way I can see to help that situation without overstepping territory that belongs to someone else, is to make sure that I do my best not to view people poorly for things that are none of my business (or at least not spread that view even if I can't help having it).
There's so much more I could have said, I suppose, but I didn't want to go into full-on lecture mode. She knew I was pretty sad about it. I think that still matters to her.
You handled that well, I think.
Quote from: NoLeDeMiel on August 28, 2014, 04:34:18 PM
My daughter and her mom have started beefing about the appropriateness of clothing choices.
She's thirteen. A bit of a hellion, but much less so than either her mother or I were at that age. I am kind of unable to get my head around clothing being an issue, but I always have to be mindful of how much residual "oi, oi, oi" I have left in me. And with some people that I respect a lot so adamant in defense of proper and adequate coverage, or whatever the standard is, I'm kind of shaky on where I stand.
Speaking of people I respect a lot, any opinions from the spag gallery?
***I did not mean to post this is AI. If someone wants to pop it over to Apple Talk, that's where it was meant to live.
I gave my kids as much latitude in that direction as they wanted.
Quote from: NoLeDeMiel on June 03, 2015, 07:54:33 AM
Gah. And then all these months later my girl makes a FB post about how girls need to show more self respect and stop "dressing like that." This possibility was very much on my mind when her mom started restricting her clothing choices. It's so tricky when we're not on the same page.
She got a lot of likes from a lot of the adults in her life. Not from me. We had a PM conversation instead about slut-shaming and agency and respect and stuff and stuff. She finally tells me that she doesn't like seeing people make decisions that are going to cause them to be viewed poorly. I told her that we care about the same things...people not being viewed poorly, but that the only way I can see to help that situation without overstepping territory that belongs to someone else, is to make sure that I do my best not to view people poorly for things that are none of my business (or at least not spread that view even if I can't help having it).
There's so much more I could have said, I suppose, but I didn't want to go into full-on lecture mode. She knew I was pretty sad about it. I think that still matters to her.
I think you did exactly the right parental thing. I hope she takes what you said to heart, because really, it's true.
There's also a deeper layer that hopefully she will unpack on her own, which is that she is saying "self-respect" but actually what it means is "dress in a way that others will respect".
Quote from: Mesozoic Mister Nigel on June 03, 2015, 04:34:34 PM
There's also a deeper layer that hopefully she will unpack on her own, which is that she is saying "self-respect" but actually what it means is "dress in a way that others will respect".
That hadn't dawned on me. It's true.
This might sound perverse, but sometimes the enforcement of prudish clothes on daughters by mothers originates from envy that they are receiving more "attention" than themselves... just throwing it out there.
Quote from: The Johnny on June 03, 2015, 06:06:40 PM
This might sound perverse, but sometimes the enforcement of prudish clothes on daughters by mothers originates from envy that they are receiving more "attention" than themselves... just throwing it out there.
I am sure that is sometimes true. However, I think it is far more often based in worry about their daughters receiving unwanted sexual attention from older men, at an age where they haven't even quite clocked what that really means. Consider the fact that clothes that were completely appropriate on a 10-year-old may be "too revealing" on a 12-year-old, or that a child may be eager to show off her newly curvy body without having yet experienced creepy, predatory behavior from adult men. While these experiences are sadly inevitable (try riding the bus as a 15-year-old girl, it's pretty awful) mothers often want to protect their daughters from it for as long as possible.
Although honestly, I see the enforcement of wearing modest clothes coming from fathers far more often than from mothers.