Who wants to play a game? (Or: Humor Me, I'm Bored)

[Cuddlefish]

Oh, and Cram, hahahahahaha!!!!

but dude, am I right? You didn't answer my PM.  this is super frustrating, because either I've either figured it out and you made a mistake, or I'm totally off base. EITHER WAY, HITTING REFRESH OVER AND OVER AGAIN IS DRIVING ME CRAZY

I got back to you. Sorry, it took me a minute. Was trying to keep up on this. But, the last clue I gave is a very important one.

A gay skydiver??? 

No

17 Guesses left.

But, for the record, there are gay skydivers.

[Cuddlefish]

Cram, there are no ugly hookers, but there is a classy lady

[The Rev]

a chinese dance group

[Cramulus]

I get it now, but the special rule you're highlighing frustrated the fuck out of me. GO FUCK YOURSELF AND YOUR RULES EXCEPTIONS DIMO

[Cuddlefish]

I get it now, but the special rule you're highlighing frustrated the fuck out of me. GO FUCK YOURSELF AND YOUR RULES EXCEPTIONS DIMO

[Cuddlefish]

a chinese dance group

16.

[Q. G. Pennyworth]

peanut butter
asparagus
Whitney Houston
Snuffleupagusses
pretty flowers
buttons
a cup of coffee
billboards
the number 19
plastic dolls
your face
potatoes
an apple peeler
nothing
robots
a lump of clay
trains

okay, that's seventeen, what's the thing?

[The Rev]

peanut butter
asparagus
Whitney Houston
Snuffleupagusses
pretty flowers
buttons
a cup of coffee
billboards
the number 19
plastic dolls
your face
potatoes
an apple peeler
nothing
robots
a lump of clay
trains

okay, that's seventeen, what's the thing?

He's having a baby.

[Cramulus]

I get it now, but the special rule you're highlighing frustrated the fuck out of me. GO FUCK YOURSELF AND YOUR RULES EXCEPTIONS DIMO

sorry dude, I just got frustrated
good puzzle

but I do not have the patience to think about this anymore

[Cuddlefish]

peanut butter
asparagus
Whitney Houston
Snuffleupagusses
pretty flowers
buttons
a cup of coffee
billboards
the number 19
plastic dolls
your face
potatoes
an apple peeler
nothing
robots
a lump of clay
trains

okay, that's seventeen, what's the thing?

Ok: yes
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no
no

1 guess left... derp

[Q. G. Pennyworth]

CURSES!

[Cuddlefish]

He's having a baby.

[The Rev]

SPILL THE BEANS YOU EMICIATED LITTLE TWIT OR IF WE EVER MEET I WILL HAVE YOUR TESTICLES ON A PLATE WITH HOT SAUCE!!!

[Q. G. Pennyworth]

TESTICLES

now tell us the damn thing!

[Triple Zero]

I don't think that Trip's should count since he was using it as an example to figure out how to do the game rather than to actively make a guess.

FTR cholera spray hose was an actual guess. I already knew mostly how the game was played, was just getting some clarification and I figured I should get things started a bit and not just ask a shitload of questions.

Now I gotta catch up with the rest of the thread