Quote from: chaotic neutral observer on July 08, 2019, 03:22:22 AMQuote from: Nephew Twiddleton on July 08, 2019, 02:58:54 AMQuote from: chaotic neutral observer on July 07, 2019, 07:56:59 PMQuote from: Nephew Twiddleton on July 07, 2019, 07:40:56 PMThis thought experiment is predicated on the aliens contacting us. I think that, compared to a species that can communicate and/or travel across interstellar distances, we would likely be little more than ants. And even if they aren't very different from us in terms of intellectual capacity, they would likely view us as a primitive people purely because of the technology gap. (And interstellar technology is a hell of a gap, compared to where we are now. Larger than the gap from a stone hammer to a smartphone, I think).
The ants analogy is somewhat of an inept one, I think. Aliens aren't necessarily going to be more advanced than us, especially if they can't manage interstellar travel, and if they're less advanced than us, we're not going to hear from them anyway
Aliens that can't contact us aren't really in the scope of this thread.
The thought experiment has them contacting us which means they don't consider us like ants
I guess I did not express my meaning clearly. I meant contact in the sense of them sending a message we are capable of receiving, or in visiting this planet, not in the sense of establishing some sort of meaningful two-way communication. Any message they sent would be intended for species they believed to be their equals, and I doubt we would qualify.
I have personally made contact with ants, and I still considered them to be ants afterward. I do not think this contact was a positive experience from the ants point-of-view (if they can be said to have such a thing).
Why do you doubt that we would qualify? If we were capable of receiving, deciphering, and responding to their message, not only are we roughly their technological equals, but they're also thinking like us.