Cool article! Really makes me question the efficacy of neurofeedback as treatment.
This. Everything I've read about neurofeedback, including stuff in medical journals makes this leap concerning correlation and cause. Most of the ADD studies are basically: Well, we see an excess of theta waves and less than normal beta waves on EEG in ADHD patients. We'll just train their brain to produce more beta and less theta then they'll be cured. No more ADHD.
Despite the fact that all they have is correlation and we still don't know what else the different wave forms could mean. When you get into amatuers attempting to do neurofeedback they jump to conclusions even quicker. There may be a place for neurofeedback in therapy but no one really knows for sure and the implications haven't been studied enough. Also most of the papers published on neurofeedback are from the doctors who are charging money for it. Reminds me of the grasshoppers with no legs can't hear joke.
Super cool articles and very relevant to my interests.
Quote from: TALK TO ME ABOUT YOUR GENITALS on August 17, 2013, 10:43:17 PMQuoteDr. John Krystal, Editor of Biological Psychiatry commented, "These data shed interesting light into the drive to achieve social status, a basic social process. It would make sense that people who had higher levels of D2 receptors, i.e., were more highly motivated and engaged by social situations, would be high achievers and would have higher levels of social support."
WHOA WHOA WHOA SAY WHAT? Back that train up! Did this guy really just attribute cause and effect to this correlation? And worse, did he really just make a statement which implies that there is a biological basis for poverty?
FUCK NO.
But he did. He said that.
This. Everything I've read about neurofeedback, including stuff in medical journals makes this leap concerning correlation and cause. Most of the ADD studies are basically: Well, we see an excess of theta waves and less than normal beta waves on EEG in ADHD patients. We'll just train their brain to produce more beta and less theta then they'll be cured. No more ADHD.
Despite the fact that all they have is correlation and we still don't know what else the different wave forms could mean. When you get into amatuers attempting to do neurofeedback they jump to conclusions even quicker. There may be a place for neurofeedback in therapy but no one really knows for sure and the implications haven't been studied enough. Also most of the papers published on neurofeedback are from the doctors who are charging money for it. Reminds me of the grasshoppers with no legs can't hear joke.
Super cool articles and very relevant to my interests.