The BIP is not a Discordian work: discuss

[Bebek Sincap Ratatosk]

So we all agree.  The BIP is a Discordian work and nobody is an asshat.  What's next on the agenda? 

Nobody is probably an asshat... though, he may also just be inarticulate in his critique.

Otherwise, anal sounds fun!

[tyrannosaurus vex]

did we just have a canonization council?

NT: Is anal Discordian?

[LMNO]

Yes.  Because much chaos can result.

















Especially if you're both eating beets.

[tyrannosaurus vex]

Yes.  Because much chaos can result.

















Especially if you're both eating beets.

I wonder if Lois Lane likes it.

[Bebek Sincap Ratatosk]

Well, given who the founders of Discordianism were... my guess is any position with any number of individuals, or chairs in any orifice is Discordian.

[AFK]

Do the orifice chairs have built-in lumbar support?  That is very important you know. 

[AFK]

So we all agree.  The BIP is a Discordian work and nobody is an asshat.  What's next on the agenda? 

Nobody is probably an asshat... though, he may also just be inarticulate in his critique.

Otherwise, anal sounds fun!

Oh I'm pretty sure somebody is an asshat, nobody knows the true scope. 

[Bebek Sincap Ratatosk]

Do the orifice chairs have built-in lumbar support?  That is very important you know. 

"I'm a Lumbar-jack and I'm OK"

[P3nT4gR4m]

So we all agree.  The BIP is a Discordian work and nobody is an asshat.

Not so quick kiddo! The Scottish Empire has not reached a satisfactory conclusion on this issue.

Moar alcohol required.

*edit* Also the Scottish Empire demands it's own emote on this websiet.

MODS!!! 

[AFK]

But I'm an Honorary Scott, remember?  Don't I get some say? 

[P3nT4gR4m]

But I'm an Honorary Scott, remember?  Don't I get some say? 

YUO JUST SPELLED 'SCOT' WITH TWO T'S

STATUS RESCINDED AND BOUNTY PLACED ON YER HEID

[AFK]

But I'm an Honorary Scott, remember?  Don't I get some say? 

YUO JUST SPELLED 'SCOT' WITH TWO T'S

STATUS RESCINDED AND BOUNTY PLACED ON YER HEID

That's how it looks on my birth certificate. 

[Cain]

So we all agree.  The BIP is a Discordian work and nobody is an asshat.

Not so quick kiddo! The Scottish Empire has not reached a satisfactory conclusion on this issue.

Moar alcohol required.

*edit* Also the Scottish Empire demands it's own emote on this websiet.

MODS!!! 

This?

[Mesozoic Mister Nigel]

What I wonder is what people are hoping to accomplish with criticism of the BIP?

I haven't read it. I read part of it, then stopped. Sorry guys!

But, so the fuck what?

Taking to the authors a critique of a work that's not going to be revised seems kind of pointless to me. Sort of like finding someone's Masters thesis three years after they presented it, and giving them a fine-comb critique of it. What benefit is there, and to whom? What is the relevance? The student has graduated.

Take what you can use, discard the rest. Think for yourself. Write your own according to your reasoning.

[Cain]