WEREWOLF II

[Fredfredly ⊂(◉‿◉)つ]

he got a guess last night before he got eaten too

[hooplala]

Hmmmm...

[hooplala]

Ok, changing mine again...

I re-vote to lynch FP.

FP: 2
Fred: 1

[Captain Utopia]

he got a guess last night before he got eaten too

Unless he was eaten before he could make a guess?

Time for some proper logical induction.

P1: AtD was definitely the psychic. 

Agreed.

P2: AtD has no reason to lie about FP and Semaj, because he is dead.

The character AtD is playing (the dead psychic) has reason to lie about who they scanned if they have a strong suspicion -- from his perspective, if he is right then "the ends justify the means".  It's okay to have suspicions - it's hard not to.

But it is extremely unlikely that AtD would be lucky enough to pin two wolves with the only two guesses he had before his untimely death.  If so, then it is an admission that it is sufficient to work out who is a wolf based purely upon whether or not they are logically consistent.  Which is good news for us because we are now without a psychic.  But we shouldn't get carried away.

AtD is basically saying that they are smarter than everyone who voted for anyone other than his suspicions.

[bds]

I vote to lynch FP.

FP - 3
Fred - 1

[Jasper]

Doesn't satisfy my suspicion.  

FP - 4
Fred - 1

ETA: Sorry dude, if you're not a werewolf, you did a good job of looking like one.

[Remington]

I can verify that Annabel received two guesses.

[LMNO]

You have to also take into account that there are THREE wolves, and AtD could have been killed by someone other than FP or Siggy.

Someone like me, for example.

[Jasper]

You have to also take into account that there are THREE wolves, and AtD could have been killed by someone other than FP or Siggy.

Someone like me, for example.

Psh wha' EVA!

*snaps his fingers in a "z"*

[Fredfredly ⊂(◉‿◉)つ]

well of course lmno some wolf could have killed him to throw suspicion on FP


but i still want to kill fp...

[The Wizard]

I vote to kill FP. He'd almost definitely a dog.

Also, why would I be a werewolf?

[bds]

We're gunna look so stupid when LMNO rips us to shreds... But I'm still voting FP.

[Jasper]

We're gunna look so stupid when LMNO rips us to shreds... But I'm still voting FP.

No!  We are being CLEVER by not taking the bait! 

[Fredfredly ⊂(◉‿◉)つ]

I vote to kill FP. He'd almost definitely a dog.

Also, why would I be a werewolf?

VOTE IN PROPER FORM SO IT COUNTS 

[The Wizard]

I vote to lynch FP. There you go.