SPIDER IV - A NEW HOPE.

[Nephew Twiddleton]

Following the lead is a very spider thing to do.  So Villager just moved on my list.  As for your protest Blight. As I have said before you are doing it too much. Again a very spider thing to do.

I hold with my vote.

Which, for the record, I have made first a few times now. I'm not a follower and spiders scare the shit out of me.

What ever you say 8-legger.

[Nephew Twiddleton]

The cabal will know their own. We'll see if BDS suspects Villager at all. YOu just want to get rid of me so you spiders will be evenly matched with the cabal. I'm only piping up now because I think I have a pretty good idea of who the spiders are.

[A Villager]

Following the lead is a very spider thing to do.  So Villager just moved on my list.  As for your protest Blight. As I have said before you are doing it too much. Again a very spider thing to do.

I hold with my vote.

Which, for the record, I have made first a few times now. I'm not a follower and spiders scare the shit out of me.

I suspect you as well but it would be a waste of a vote to go against the majority with so many spiders about. 

[Nephew Twiddleton]

BDS- I recommend that you stall your vote until you confer with your cabal mates. It's quite simple logic now that Khara and Villager suspect each other. One of them has to be a spider. If Khara is in your cabal, then Villager is a spider, and therefore, I probably am too. If Villager is in your cabal, then Khara is a spider, and I am most likely a citizen. Be sure that your cabal votes in accord. This may be the only chance that you get to win the game at this point.

Methinks the game will soon be over.

[A Villager]

BDS- I recommend that you stall your vote until you confer with your cabal mates. It's quite simple logic now that Khara and Villager suspect each other. One of them has to be a spider. If Khara is in your cabal, then Villager is a spider, and therefore, I probably am too. If Villager is in your cabal, then Khara is a spider, and I am most likely a citizen. Be sure that your cabal votes in accord. This may be the only chance that you get to win the game at this point.

Methinks the game will soon be over.

And I was a spider in the last game. Blight sold me out after seeing my email. remember?

[Nephew Twiddleton]

BDS- I recommend that you stall your vote until you confer with your cabal mates. It's quite simple logic now that Khara and Villager suspect each other. One of them has to be a spider. If Khara is in your cabal, then Villager is a spider, and therefore, I probably am too. If Villager is in your cabal, then Khara is a spider, and I am most likely a citizen. Be sure that your cabal votes in accord. This may be the only chance that you get to win the game at this point.

Methinks the game will soon be over.

And I was a spider in the last game. Blight sold me out after seeing my email. remember?

And I'll do it again. What do you say Khara and Villager? If BDS says Khara is in the cabal, I will change my vote to Villager. If he says Villager is in the cabal, I am going to vote Khara. Granted, this outs a Discordian, but after this round it won't matter. The Machine won't be built. Is that cool with both of you?

(retracting vote for Khara pending further info)

[Nephew Twiddleton]

Blight   Posted
Nigel  Posted
Freeky   Luna
Khara   Blight
Luna   Blight
BDS   
Villager   Khara

Revised

[Nephew Twiddleton]

I'd also like to point out at this point the following:

Both Khara and Jenne voted for BDS after it was proven that he was a Discordian. They can claim suspicion of Roger if they want, except that even at the time the Spiders didn't find each other, but in that round a Discordian was converted. Roger suddenly changed his tune and said BDS is definitely not a spider. That all but gave both of them away as Discordians. They can also claim missing it if they wanted, but basically knowing who a Discordian is at that point is pretty damn important and you would make damn sure that you weren't voting off a Discordian. They then retracted there votes each time Roger pointed it out.

EoC tried to help the Cabal, and got subsumed.

I gave some pretty solid advice to the cabal, and now Khara wants to get rid of me.

Going back on the thread, there has been nothing that Khara has said to help the Discordians, only to cast suspicion in the wrong places.

I'm going to call my suspicions now. It's Khara and Jenne. The third spider at that point becomes obvious to the cabal.

Khara can say I protest too much, and I'm sure she will, but why the hell would I basically guarantee a loss for the spiders if I was one? So, fuck yeah I'm protesting too much, I want you goddamn spiders out of my goddamn city.

[Mesozoic Mister Nigel]

Waitasecond. I'm Jenne now... what is it I'm supposed to be?

Holy shit, I am so confused.

[Nephew Twiddleton]

Waitasecond. I'm Jenne now... what is it I'm supposed to be?

Holy shit, I am so confused.

If my logic is sound, you're one of the bad guys, but we'll worry about that later. Right now the proof is between Khara and Villager. If BDS confirms that one of them is the good guys, then that means the other one is one of the bad guys.

[Nephew Twiddleton]

Also, this round is going to play out in the following possible ways:

I get put on a bus. End result, the Discordians no longer have enough votes to vote off a Spider. The Spiders form the Machine, and crush the Discordians one by one. Game over in 4 rounds.

A spider gets put on the bus, and the Discordians now out number the Spiders, and vote them off one by one. Game ends in Revolution, game over in 3 rounds.

Either way it will be a first.  Hoping for the Revolution. Seems like something not likely to happen again for a long time, and I want to see the narration for it.

[bds]

It's Khara. Or it's YOU, Blight! But I suspect Khara a little more. If that was a ploy on your part, congratulations.

I'm voting for Khara, and I would urge everybody else to change.

Blight   Posted
Nigel  Posted
Freeky   Luna
Khara   Blight
Luna   Blight
BDS Khara
Villager   Khara

Revised

[bds]

Either way, it's going right down to the wire. This shit is tense!

[Mesozoic Mister Nigel]

How do we are supposed to be able to tell who is a bad guy and who is a good guy?

I'm sorry for being confused, I've just completely ignored these threads until now!

[bds]

Logic/guesswork/total fucking luck. In general, somebody will post a theory on who they suspect, and everybody sort of follows that. Of course, you don't know about the motives of the person who posted a theory, so it gets tricky.