D&D pseudo-noob reporting for duty! (i did start on AD&D second edition, though i have not played nearly as much nor as hardcorely as you guys).
FWIW, i'll pitch in with the "don't like 4e" camp, as the only campaign i have ever played on it (and ended up leaving halfway through because of the group itself, although that is not the games fault) i did not enjoy as much as the games i've played of 3/3.5/p.finder, let alone the ones with the original party i started with on 2nd edition.
sooooo.... there we have it. i think i'm the first on the thread to say i did not like 4e because i simply enjoyed the other editions more

(and i still miss non-weapon proficiencies

).
*cowers in fear from the mighty DnD powerhouses he just wandered between while awaiting judgement*
oh yeah, and demi-lich > tarrasque, but the tarrasque is a lot cooler.